By If/When/How
Today, If/When/How: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice and BraunHagey & Borden LLP filed the first-ever civil rights lawsuit under California’s Reproductive Privacy Act (RPA). Passed in 2022, the RPA prohibits government officials from criminalizing, threatening, or intimidating a person for having a miscarriage, stillbirth, or abortion. The lawsuit was filed on behalf of a young Los Angeles woman who, while enduring the trauma of a miscarriage at 29 weeks, was interrogated by the LAPD and then subjected to a year-long criminal investigation.
City of Los Angeles officials violated Jane Doe’s rights under the RPA and other California laws when they shackled, interrogated, and threatened her with murder charges even after medical records confirmed she had miscarried. From day one, LAPD detectives were informed that medical staff had diagnosed Ms. Doe as miscarrying a deceased fetus. Yet, LAPD and the City Attorney continued investigating Ms. Doe for murder for over a year until finally telling her they were bringing no charges against her.
“The City’s inexplicable, heartless, and illegal conduct prolonged and worsened Ms. Doe’s trauma,” said Sara L. Ainsworth, Chief Legal & Policy Director at If/When/How. “No one should ever be criminalized for how their pregnancy ends, in any state. The California Legislature passed AB 2223 to put an end to this wrongful criminalization in California once and for all. Ms. Doe deserves justice for what the City of Los Angeles did to her.”
In November of 2024, Jane Doe was unhoused and on medication that caused her to have irregular menstrual cycles. After seeking medical care for intense stomach pain, Ms. Doe learned she was experiencing a miscarriage. Ms. Doe was sent away to pass the pregnancy on her own, with only a pamphlet for first-trimester miscarriage self-care. Medical records from that day show that Ms. Doe was actually approximately 29 weeks pregnant with a deceased fetus and should have been admitted for medical care.
After Ms. Doe returned to the city shelter where she lived, Ms. Doe unknowingly passed her pregnancy in the shared communal bathroom and began heavily bleeding. When paramedics arrived, they dismissed her pain as a normal miscarriage and denied her need for medical care. Knowing something was not right, Ms. Doe insisted they take her to the hospital, afraid she would bleed to death.
In the midst of her medical treatment for significant blood loss and stillbirth, while she was in shock, in pain, and in fear for her life, LAPD officers showed up, stood behind a thin privacy curtain, and had Ms. Doe escorted to an isolated patient room. Los Angeles police then grabbed and cuffed both of Ms. Doe’s arms to the gurney guardrails on either side of her head. She remained shackled, her hands eventually going numb, for hours while she was interrogated by LAPD detectives, who accused her of murder for what they knew was, in fact, a traumatic stillbirth that Ms. Doe had just endured.
“Ms. Doe sought help from the City in her moment of terror and was cruelly punished for it,” said BraunHagey & Borden LLP partner Marissa Benavides. “We look forward to vindicating Ms. Doe’s reproductive rights and dignity, and hope to see these protections inspire the rest of the nation.”
The illegal and abusive treatment Ms. Doe faced at the hands of the LAPD did not end in the hospital. Instead, for the next year, LAPD detectives investigated Ms. Doe for homicide.
After a year of investigating, questioning, and threatening her with murder charges, the LA City Attorney’s office finally told Ms. Doe that they would not be filing any charges against her.
“What Ms. Doe was forced to endure was horrific and senseless. Ms. Doe deserved support, compassion, and healthcare — not criminalization,” said Shantal McNeil, Litigation Counsel at If/When/How, and one of Ms. Doe’s criminal defense attorneys during the City’s investigation. “This lawsuit shows why it is essential that states pass laws banning pregnancy criminalization while ensuring that people can hold their government to account for violating those rights. It is not enough to outlaw pregnancy criminalization on paper. We must ensure government actors are held accountable so Ms. Doe receives justice, and that no other person ever has to experience what the City of Los Angeles put her through.”
California is one of the thirteen states, plus D.C., that have banned pregnancy criminalization, and the only state in the country that directly eliminates common legal immunities for law enforcement. Jane Doe’s treatment shows that we need laws like California’s Reproductive Privacy Act, but that law on its own can’t change a culture that stigmatizes and punishes people for their pregnancy outcomes.
Ms. Doe brings this lawsuit to seek justice for the trauma the City of Los Angeles put her through, to vindicate her rights protected by the Reproductive Privacy Act and other California laws, and to ensure that no one else is subjected to the same mistreatment and violation of civil rights because of their pregnancy outcome.
→ Read the full complaint on Jane Doe v. City of Los Angeles
TAKE ACTION
→ Sign up to be part of the fight to change the laws in your state. Working with state partners is essential to our strategy. We don’t parachute into states to take over work, but we build intentional relationships and pass laws with partners that make sense for each state.
→ Learn more about your rights when seeking medical care after an abortion or pregnancy.
→ Read more about the California Reproductive Privacy Act that we helped pass with Black Women for Wellness Action Project, ACLU of California, California Latinas for Reproductive Justice, Reproductive Freedom for All California, and Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California.